Skip to main content

The 3 elements affecting appreciation of a photograph

Shell fish on Cornish rocks wait for the incoming tide to return.

The premise for this article is that there are three basic elements which affect our perception and therefore appreciation of a photograph. I arrived at this conclusion during a typically philosophical breakfast conversation with my dear wife, Magda.

Never mind breakfast, I hear you say, what are these three elements. Well the first is obviously the image itself. Secondly we have the viewer’s personal life experience which filters the image and influences the way they perceive it. The third ingredient is for me the eureka one, and a rather slippery customer to pin down. I’ll call it visual fashion or probably more accurately ‘learnt perception.’

Number one, the image itself is self explanatory really. Here I mean the subject matter but also the visual presentation (colour, black and white) as well as objective technical aspects, including saturation, sharpness, composition etc but excluding any interpretation or judgement of these elements.

When we view an image we respond to the content subjectively. Nobody can look at an image objectively. What you see is affected by your life experience. Reactions can be profoundly different. For example a simple image like the one above of the mussels on the rocks can have one person dreaming of a wonderful meal while another will see danger and someone else will remember playing on rocks like these as a child. The number of emotions, memories and interpretations are as many and varied as the number of viewers.

The third element is the difficult one to nail down. We learn from a young age how to view photographs and throughout our lives this process continues. It is influenced by our culture, exposure to images, knowledge and interest in photography.

Many years ago a friend, the photojournalist TJ Lemon, sent me a picture of himself at Victoria Falls. He was lying behind a rock and all you could see was his head and the tips of his fingers. The visual joke was that it looked like he was hanging over the edge of the cliff. Our minds fill in the fact that his body is on the other side of the rock. He had a desperate expression on his face, acting the part of a climber clinging onto the ledge for dear life.

I happened to show this picture to some African tribesman shortly after receiving it from TJ. There was much consternation and horror. When I asked them what was causing the upset they said that the photo was horrific. They thought that his head had been chopped off and placed on the rock because all they saw was his head. Not being used to interpreting photographs they read the image very literally.

In our image literate cultures we are so used to seeing things in two dimensions that it is very easy to take it fore granted that everyone looks at a picture in the same way. Nothing could be further from the truth. Like word literacy there is a whole range of visual literacy and levels of being able to interpret and read images.

Taking this a step further, people educated in photography, naturally bring certain technical biases to bear when reading an image. They have an extra filter between themselves and the image.

Technical knowledge gives the viewer another level on which to appreciate an image but it may also get in the way of unlocking the direct emotional connection that can exist with the picture. The element we get through connecting an image directly to our experience of the world.

Everyone, whether aware of technique or a layperson, is influenced by fashions and the visual culture of the day. Just in the same way that language constantly changes, for example the slang terms we use, images and their appreciation are subject to the trends of the day. Technology, like using digital cameras and being able to instantly publish an image world-wide, has influenced the look of photography.

As I’ve mentioned in this blog before, different photo sharing sites have different cultures and an image that does well on one site will not necessarily do well on another.

Clearly cultural and sub-culture interpretation of images hugely affects the audience’s appreciation of an image. Each sub-culture has its own memes.

I hope this article reveals how subjective our judgement is of photography. Despite this subjectivity there are theories that within certain cultural parameters we are able to recognise and appreciate pure creativity. This applies particularly to the pure fine arts like painting. Photography is not quite the same thing or on the same level as sculpture, painting and music. It is a category apart although it can be an art. So despite all the cultural filters and influences of fashion and taste, on one level we may be able to recognise great creativity, albeit in a general sense. Or perhaps not.

If you have any views then I would love to hear them.

Till soon,

Paul

Comments

Paul said…
Great post - very interesting read. Please feel free to post this to www.photographyvoter.com
Frank said…
I hope you and Magda have many more of these philosophical breakfeasts, Paul... for the outcome of your discussion really makes sense to me.

However true your words, also about the timeframe an image has before it gets 'stale', I'm sure there are pictures that survive throughout the times. I bought the NatGeo publication of 100 pictures that didn't make it to the mag, but of which the photographers think it's among their best. A big percentage of these pics is IMO very much worth looking at, even though the timeframe they depict is history - though recent history.

Anyway, this is an excellent article. Thanks!

All the best,



Frank
Frank said…
I hope you and Magda have many more of these philosophical breakfeasts, Paul... for the outcome of your discussion really makes sense to me.

However true your words, also about the timeframe an image has before it gets 'stale', I'm sure there are pictures that survive throughout the times. I bought the NatGeo publication of 100 pictures that didn't make it to the mag, but of which the photographers think it's among their best. A big percentage of these pics is IMO very much worth looking at, even though the timeframe they depict is history - though recent history.

Anyway, this is an excellent article. Thanks!

All the best,



Frank

Popular posts from this blog

The art of writing a caption

A caption in its simplest form is the the title of an image but usually we mean a bit more. A full caption takes the form of descriptive text, usually a few sentences.

A good caption informs us about the things we cannot see and encourages us to look at an image more closely. There is a relationship of mutual benefit and dependence between a well written caption and an image. The caption can bring an image to life by providing context and meaning. It is also the link between the article/story/text and the image.

Magda Indigo has written a good description of a caption here. I agree with her dislike of "untitled". It does show a certain lack of imagination and is not particularly helpful to the viewer. Creating an image is all about trying to communicate something and the caption is vital to help the audience understand an image. It can hugely enhance the viewers experience.

A good caption is a piece of writing that should be concise, accurate, informative and as carefully craft…

All the different types of photography

Welcome to my blog. While you're here why not browse through my extensive library of articles covering everything from tips on how to do things photographic to help with the mental approach you need to become a successful photographer. You'll also find articles with some of my unconventional views. Yes, I've rattled a view cages in my time. Hope you have as much fun reading them as I did writing them.

You can view my more serious work on www.indigo2photography.co.uk

All the different types of photography

With the help of acquaintances on a photographic site I've tried to compile a list of all the different types of photography out there. I'm sure there are many still missing but the list is pretty impressive so far. We have identified around 80 descriptions.

For fun I've highlighted in bold the different types I've done so far...

3D photography
Action photography
Advertising photography
Aerial photography
Amateur photography
Animal photography
Architecture photography

Art of the decisive moment

Capturing the decisive moment requires patience and timing. Good timing depends on your ability to anticipate the right moment.


Welcome to my relaunched blog. You'll notice a new design to mark the moment. What do you think?

The plan is to write far more regularly. Short posts. Easy to read. Focused on a single subject.

This time it's about that vital element. The anticipation of the decisive moment.

As a scene unfolds you're thinking about what is going to happen next. Where are people moving to? What are they doing? What's happening in the background? Do you have the right point of view or do you need to move?

To be ready for the moment you need a prepared mind and a prepared camera. I almost never use burst mode. It's too inaccurate. While the shutter is clattering away you're not seeing what is about to happen. You run the risk that the exact split second you should have snapped is between frames. I prefer the approach of taking a single shot, relying on t…